-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 56
Locally orderable spaces are radial #1614
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
base: main
Are you sure you want to change the base?
Conversation
|
One could shorten the proof of the thm by just saying Radial is a "local property" (which is being proved as part of the theorem here) and using LOTS => radial. I just went with this longer way. |
|
Looks T774~T777 seem to be preserved by #1426? |
|
good point. I'll change the number. |
|
The metaprop that Radial (P172) is a "local property" is simple enough, so there should be no need to justify it with a mathse post or a reference to some book/paper. Based on that, one could just shorten the justification of the theorem to the following:
Would that be preferable? |
|
@prabau to me, yes |
|
@prabau actually, why the quotation marks? |
|
because we have not defined what it means. It could mean different things in general. In this case, it's referring to what is spelled out as one of the meta-properties, but I did not feel like repeating all that. If that's too terse, we may as well give more details about the proof. Note: @StevenClontz has suggested that in the future there will be some kind of dictionary of often used terms in pi-base. If that happens, we can better define what we mean and have links to suitable definitions. |
|
A property being "local" is a well defined notion (at least in Algebra(ic Geometry) and apparently also in topology), so the quotes are not necessary. A rather rudimentary formalisation of this in Lean would be :) |
|
π-base wiki Conventions and Style has already specify how local properties means. |
Technically this only says given a property |
|
Having: "This property is (weakly?) local." might be useful as a metaproperty in general actually |
New theorem: Locally orderable => radial.
Plus some metaproperties for Radial. I added "not preserved by products" because it was not initially obvious, and could be surprising to some.
This theorem allows to derive two more spaces are radial: S40 (altered long ray) and S196 (long circle),
and two more spaces are not locally orderable: S109 (Novak space) and S110 (strong ultrafilter topology).